
To be clear, as of 2020, the risk that human CAPTCHA solvers present is now more or less manageable (if not solved) for multiple reasons. Depending on the solver’s speed, that puts their pay anywhere from $2 to $5 per day. The solver networks, however, only pay workers roughly USD $0.40 for 1,000 correct solutions. These services cost attackers (that is, the customers of the solver service) roughly USD $1-$3 per 1,000 correct solutions, depending on the service and type of puzzle. 3įor more than a decade, however, attackers have had the ability to circumvent CAPTCHAs at scale and speed, not through advances in computer vision or artificial intelligence, but by identifying and farming out the puzzles to networks of human workers (known in this industry as solvers) in developing economies, and then returning the correct responses so that bots can continue on their assigned task. Google’s latest version of their reCAPTCHA tool, version 3, transparently analyzes user behavior in the browser instead of requiring specific human input. Over time, CAPTCHAs have come to include different types of puzzles, including identifying specific objects within a complex image, transcribing short audio files, or solving logical puzzles, such as turning an image right-side up. In the beginning, these puzzles were mostly visual, and usually required users to parse distorted text and type it in. 2 CAPTCHAs weed out bots by presenting puzzles within the browser’s response that ostensibly only humans can solve. 1 This component is designed to identify and block bots that attackers use to automate and scale up attacks such as credential abuse, web scraping, or, in the case of tools like sneaker bots, to quickly buy up limited supplies of commodities like fashionable sneakers. Few technologies better exemplify this arms race than the web element known as CAPTCHA. Information security often takes the form of an arms race, as attackers develop novel ways to use or abuse services on the web to their own benefit, and defenders scramble to adapt to and block these new techniques.
